Out of Your Depth, Still in Command: Senior Leaders Leading Technical Teams

By Stephanie Bickel

How do you effectively lead a team when you are not the subject matter expert in their work? This question surfaces often for leaders stepping into unfamiliar technical domains, especially in fast-evolving fields like IT or engineering. It's a humbling place to be: responsible for outcomes, yet unable to do the work yourself.

You do not need to be an expert in your team’s domain to be a strong leader. In fact, you can be an even better leader precisely because you are not caught in the weeds. However, if you don't reframe your role and communicate your value, you risk being sidelined or ignored.

Many leaders believe they must "speak the language" or master the details of their team’s technical world to earn respect. That belief is a myth. The reality is, teams don’t need a second subject matter expert. They need a leader who can see the big picture, connect roles, create clarity, and remove roadblocks.

When you're leading a team outside your area of expertise, your value is in your vantage point. You are the conductor, not the violinist. Focus on three things:

1. Clarify the Hand-offs: Be obsessed with the flow. Understand how work moves from one person to the next, and simplify the transitions. Think end-to-end.

2. Communicate Your Role Clearly: Help your team understand what you bring to the table—strategy, customer insights, executive visibility, process rigor, or stakeholder alignment. Fill the gap they can't.

3. Foster Mutual Learning: Let them teach you their world, while you teach them yours. Draw parallels between their domain and yours. Share how your experience can enhance their impact.

One leader shared that their most successful manager had no background in tech. What that leader brought instead was business acumen, client relationships, and executive storytelling. The team flourished because she created opportunities, removed friction, and celebrated wins.

Another success factor? Weekly meetings that started with humor and ended with empowerment. One manager opened team calls with movie clips, asking, "How is this like us?" It created levity, built connection, and framed complex discussions in relatable ways.

One non-technical leader shared that she didn’t try to fake technical knowledge. Instead, she focused on safety protocols and user protection procedures. She helped the team connect their platform designs to real human outcomes. Her clarity and respect for their expertise earned their trust. And in turn, they became more open to her ideas.

Another leader used a "Fast and Slow" questionning technique. Team members identified where work was flowing well (fast) and where inefficiencies existed (slow). It led to targeted improvements and cross-team learning. The manager didn’t need to know the code. They just needed to ask the right questions.

Imagine your team sees you as the glue—the person who unites specialties, simplifies communication, and elevates performance. They don’t see you as a technical peer, but as an indispensable guide. Your meetings are energizing. Your questions unlock insights. Your feedback is welcomed because it’s rooted in care and clarity.

You lead not by knowing what they know, but by seeing what they miss.

And that, in the end, is what makes you irreplaceable.

__________________________________________________________________________________

Want to learn more from Speak by Design University. In our "live" group coaching meetings, professionals share their struggles and breakthroughs at work. This is a supportive group that uses communication skills and mindset shifts to become the leader you are meant to be. speakbydesign.com/join